Information

Have there been any “chopstick gene” mistakes in genetics?

Have there been any “chopstick gene” mistakes in genetics?


We are searching data for your request:

Forums and discussions:
Manuals and reference books:
Data from registers:
Wait the end of the search in all databases.
Upon completion, a link will appear to access the found materials.

I've heard of the "chopstick gene" fallacy - wrongly assuming an association between genetics and some characteristic, confounded by non-genetic factors.

Has this fallacy happened in real life?

I'm not really interested in cases deliberately focusing on race, where people have argued that there's an innate difference between people of different races based on certain genetic differences, such as the putative "warrior gene" ("warrior allele"?) being described as more common in Maori people. As far as I can tell, the "chopstick gene" isn't about arguing that Asian people are better with chopsticks because of genetic differences between Asians and non-Asians.

I'm more interested in research that was done in good faith, which ignored the possibility of genetic variations having different frequencies in different groups, that produced erroneous conclusions.


Have a look at this time article from a couple years ago.

A concept that you should think about is nature vs nurture. You can think of nature (your genetics) as controlling part of the potential of what you could become (for example, many long distance athletes have genetics that are beneficial for their sport) where as nurture encapsulates the environment that you grow up in (a nutritionally deficient child will not reach maximum potential height that you might predict based on genetics alone).

When scientists are studying a gene in relation to a phenotype, they statistical methods to determine how much a genotype contributes to a phenotype. This process would minimize these types of fallacies since different alleles in different populations would be considered. However, sampling biases can occur and most human variation studies are done on people of european, asian, and african descent.



Comments:

  1. Mikagor

    In my opinion, you are making a mistake. I propose to discuss it. Email me at PM.

  2. Chancey

    An additional possible options?

  3. Mazugami

    I advise to you to look a site, with a large quantity of articles on a theme interesting you.

  4. Randall

    Your phrase, just the grace

  5. Abdul

    The morning is wiser than the evening.

  6. Oswiu

    Hmm ... it will come in handy ...

  7. Cailin

    Your helpful opinion

  8. Malakus

    You speak factually

  9. Shea

    I accept it with pleasure. An interesting topic, I will take part. Together we can come to the right answer. I'm sure.



Write a message